It should come as no surprise that
a women's liberal arts college might offer a course in "women in music"
or that the applied music students and faculty might learn and perform works
by female composers. What is surprising is that until ten years ago, at
Agnes Scott College it was the rare exception for a female composer to be
assigned or programmed. Not only were works by women never mentioned in
music history or theory courses, but the only library book on the topic
of women in music was George Upton's Woman and Music, with its nineteenth-century
attitude that women were incapable of composing and should restrict their
musical endeavors to salon music and supporting their male friends and relatives
who composed.
Much has changed in the last ten years at academic institutions nationwide.
Although developments at this suburban Atlanta four-year college closely
resemble those at similar institutions, others are no doubt unique or at
least unusual, and might be of interest to colleagues in higher education.
Women's Studies was slow in coming to Agnes Scott, with the first course
being offered in 1978, the first director of Women's Studies being appointed
in 1989, and a minor being offered for the first time the same year.
The first concert on campus devoted solely to female composers was given
by organist-harpsichordist Calvert Johnson in February 1988. Assisting was
flutist Carol Lyn Butcher, who presented her own program devoted to works
by women the following October, accompanied by Johnson. Since then, most
of the applied music faculty have routinely assigned works by women to their
students, and both student and faculty recitals have included compositions
by women as a normal procedure to the point that it is simply not novel
anymore to hear a composition by a woman.
At the same time, the music faculty at Agnes Scott began to main-stream
women into music history and theory courses. The music history three-semester
sequence uses K. Marie Stolba's The Development of Western Music,
2nd edition (Madison: WCB, 1994) which includes extensive coverage of women
as composers, performers, etc. Music theory courses include examples of
works by women for analysis, sight-singing, and ear-training. History of
Sacred Music prominently features women as hymnists, composers, and sacred
musicians. Women are also included in such courses as Introduction to Music,
American Popular Music, History of Jazz, and Musicals and Film Music.
The college's centennial was celebrated in 1988-89. Among many other special
activities featuring the accomplishments of women in all fields, the college
commissioned Thea Musgrave to compose a work to include Singing, instrumental
music, dance, and acting. Although she typically writes her own librettos,
Musgrave asked that her friend C. E. (Christa) Cooper be commissioned to
provide the text for Echoes through Time. She also located a young
woman, Linda Brovsky, to serve as stage director and choreographer. Alumnae
Liz Lee and Margaret Clark Waterbury were set designer/lighting designer
and costumer respectively. In addition, four women were commissioned to
create temporary site sculptures based on Cooper's libretto, thus involving
all of the creative arts in a common effort.
The first course in Women in Music was offered by Johnson in the spring
of 1990, with the objective of including the accomplishments and activities
of women in music-making of all kinds in cultures throughout the world and
from antiquity to the present. This survey course used the following texts:
Ellen Koskoff, Women and Music in Cross-Cultural Perspective (Urbana:
University of Illinois Press, 1989); Carol Neuls-Bates, Women in Music:
An Anthology of Source Readings, revised edition (Boston: Northeastern
University Press, 1996); and Jane Bowers and Judith Tick, Women Making Music:
The Western Art Tradition, 1150-1950 (Urbana: University of Illinois Press,
1987).
Every year many guests are invited to give presentations to the class. Among
them have been guest artists violinist Stephanie Chase (who, at the request
of the College Events Committee, included Clara Schumann's Romances
on her recital), composer and pianist Judith Zaimont, pianist Teresa Dybvig,
and pianist Patricia Ross (who, later in the day gave her one-woman show
on Teresa Carreño). Local musicians have included members of the
Atlanta Symphony (principal clarinetist Laura Ardan, assistant principal
horn and the sole female brass player Susan Welty, violinist Alice Oglesby,
and president Allison Vulgamore), popular musicians Emily Saliers of the
Grammy-winning Indigo Girls, duo Joyce and Jacque, and Michelle Malone,
and directors of music from prominent churches (Adele Dieckmann McKee, Atlanta
BACH choir director Porter Remington, Sue Mitchell-Wallace, and current
Dean of the Atlanta chapter of the American Guild of Organists Marilyn González).
Other faculty in the music department and from neighboring colleges who
have given presentations have included Ronald Byrnside (women in American
popular music), Theodore K. Mathews and Emory University's Dwight Andrews
(both on women in jazz), and Juan Ramírez (women in Latin American
music).
The spin-off effect has been most interesting. Mathews and Andrews had always
included some coverage of women in their courses on jazz, but never to the
extent that they have since giving their presentations to the Women in Music
class. Last winter, Andrews gave a four-evening lecture series on Women
in Jazz, sponsored by the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra as part of its public
educational outreach program. Ramírez is also Director of the Atlanta
Virtuosi which annually performs a series of programs featuring Latin American
music. As a direct result of his presentation to the class, he featured
Latina composers on the next series. Similarly, Byrnside expanded coverage
of women in the second edition of his introduction to music textbook, Music:
Sound and Sense (Dubuque: WCB, 1990). Johnson was chair of the program
committee for the 1992 national convention of the American Guild of Organists
in Atlanta, which prominently featured women as composers (including commissions),
performers, and conductors. As President of the Southeastern Historical
Keyboard Society, Johnson served as co-chair with Marcelline Mayhall of
the Midwest Historical Keyboard Society of the joint meeting of their societies
in Louisville, 1993, where women were again featured, as composers instrument
builders, and performers.
By 1995 it was painfully evident that too much material was included in
the Women in Music course. The music department received the blessing of
the curriculum committee and of the college faculty to split the course
into two courses, both of which are cross-listed for credit in Women's Studies.
The course that retained the original course number became Women in Music:
the Western Tradition (from Hildegard to the present). Because of the large
number of non-music students enrolling in the course, the Bowers and Tick
textbook was replaced by Karin Pendle's Women and Music: A History
(Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1991).
The new course satisfied the desire of the music department to offer an
introduction to world music course by doing so from the woman's point of
view--Women in Music in Cross-Cultural Perspective. The course was offered
for the first time in the fall, 1996, using as textbooks Koskoff's book
and Jeff Titon, Worlds of Music, 3rd edition (New York: Schirmer
Books, 1996). Additional readings were drawn from the Pendle text (chapters
on antiquity and on world music), and several articles: Jacqueline Cogdell
Djedje, "Women and Music in Sudanic Africa," More Than Drumming:
Essays on African and Afro-Latin American Music and Musicians, ed. by
Irene V. Jackson (Westport CT: Greenwood Press, 1987), 67-89; Judy A. Jones,
"Nez Perce Women, Music and Cultural Change" Women of Note
Quarterly 3/3 (August 1995), 6-19; and Kay Hardy Campbell, "Folk
Music and Dance in the Arabian Gulf and Saudi Arabia," [unpublished
paper].
Although an introductory survey course, coverage included women's participation
in music making among the Sioux, Navajo, Nez Perce, Iroquois, Kaiapó
of Brazil, Mapuche of Argentina and Chile, Hazara of Afghanistan, Temiar
of Malaysia, and Algerian Berbers. European folk traditions featured Greece,
the Balkans, Sephardic and Lubavitcher Jewish communities. African societies
covered included the Kassena-Nankani, Ewe, Tuareg, Shona, Xhosa (featuring
Miriam Makeba), Wolof, Dongamba, Mande, BaAka Forest people. Non-Wester
classical traditions included Javanese gamelan and shadow puppet
theatre, Japanese gidayu-bunraku puppet theatre, geisha, shamisen
and koto music; India; and the Arabian music of Tunisia, Egypt (featuring
Om Kalthoum), and Saudi Arabia. Also studied were musical women of antiquity
(Egypt, Mesopotamia, Hebrews, Greeks, Romans, and medieval Arabia).
In conjunction with the course, the students were required to attend world
music concerts in Atlanta, notably a performance of Arabian music at the
college by Simon Shaheen and his Near Eastern Ensemble, given in conjunction
with an exhibit of calligraphic art works "The Right to Write"
from The Jordan National Gallery. Rehearsals of non-Western performing ensembles
were attended by the class, including the gamelan at Emory University, and
a community African drum and dance ensemble in downtown Decatur.
Regarding the original course, perhaps the most unusual development was
the introduction of a foreign language component to Women in Music: the
Western Tradition. Thus, the music department joined the college's initiative
to spread the study of foreign language across the curriculum. The purpose
of the Language Across the Curriculum program was to improve foreign language
instruction and learning through a content-based course so that students
might study original materials (frequently not otherwise available in English)
in courses within their major or minor, or to use their language abilities
in courses outside the foreign language departments. [1] In the spring of
1996, it was possible for students to enroll for an extra hour of credit
in German, Music, or Women's Studies. The additional hour was team-taught
by Ingrid Wieshofer and Johnson, with directed readings, study-guides, and
discussion entirely in German. The overall objective of the program was
summarized by Wieshofer as follows: "By linking language to other disciplines
at Agnes Scott College, we are demonstrating to students that the achievement
of foreign language competence is an integral part of liberal arts education
that will deepen their understanding of the humanities as their mastery
of the language increases." [2]
Through a grand from the National Endowment for the Humanities, Johnson
was able to study German at the Goethe Institutes in Atlanta and Berlin
from the summer of 1994 through the fall of 1995 in order to improve his
German competency. During summer of 1995, the instructors selected texts
and developed study guides that simultaneously checked German reading comprehension,
enhanced the depth and breadth of coverage in the linked music course, developed
German writing skills, and encouraged class discussion in German. "the
main emphasis was on enriching the discipline, not on adding courses in
foreign language departments." [3] The result was incredibly successful,
enriching not only the course, but also both students and instructors. The
German component will be offered every three years. In addition, a French
component will be offered in the 1997-98 academic year and every three years
thereafter, with French professor Julia De Pree joining Johnson in this
team teaching arrangement. The Women in Music course was unusual in that
every student was simultaneously enrolled in the German component as well.
Hence, class discussion in the English language disciplinary course inevitably
drew as well on the German language readings and discussion. However, even
if some students had not enrolled in the German component, they undoubtedly
would have benefited because experience in other Language Across the Curriculum
courses have clearly demonstrated "that the benefits of these courses
extend to the students who did not take the component courses. Students
in the language component classes volunteered information and asked questions
more often in the discipline classes." [4]
The syllabus of the German language component has already been put on the
world wide web at a site most likely to be accessed by German teachers (wig-l@cmsa.berkeley.edu).
Because not everyone has access to the web, the list of directed readings
and related activities is given below. Of particular note is the project
of writing a letter to a German, Austrian, or Swiss composer to learn more
about her development as a composer, her career, and her compositional style,
beyond what the student has been able to learn by reading various texts
in German.